Login or Sign Up
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Global Forums > General > Expat or Immigrant Worker?
 
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Expat or Immigrant Worker?

I saw this article in The Guardian claiming white people abroad are called "expats", while non-white people abroad are called "immigrant workers".


Do you find that to be true? Do you think most people indeed use skin-color as the main factor to decide if a foreigner is an expat or immigrant worker?


I think:


1. The article is bullshit. Most people indeed use "expat" amd "immigrant" in a different way, but it has nothing to do with skin color. For example, any foreigner working for P&G in Geneva will be called an expat, not an immigrant, regardless of skin color.


2. Most people, from what I see, are more likely to use "expat" to desribe a foreigner who has a white-collar job, while an "immigrant" is more likely to be used to describe a foreigner with a blue-collar job. There's some other definitions of expat vs immigrant online, but that's academic. In reality, I find the type of work to be the deciding factor. 


What think?


 



The text you are quoting:

I saw this article in The Guardian claiming white people abroad are called "expats", while non-white people abroad are called "immigrant workers".


Do you find that to be true? Do you think most people indeed use skin-color as the main factor to decide if a foreigner is an expat or immigrant worker?


I think:


1. The article is bullshit. Most people indeed use "expat" amd "immigrant" in a different way, but it has nothing to do with skin color. For example, any foreigner working for P&G in Geneva will be called an expat, not an immigrant, regardless of skin color.


2. Most people, from what I see, are more likely to use "expat" to desribe a foreigner who has a white-collar job, while an "immigrant" is more likely to be used to describe a foreigner with a blue-collar job. There's some other definitions of expat vs immigrant online, but that's academic. In reality, I find the type of work to be the deciding factor. 


What think?


 


Nir OfekMar 14, 2015 @ 18:51
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
 
12 Replies | 1910 Views      |  Send to friend
 
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Expat or Immigrant Worker?
Post 1

Agree to you Nir. In normal english usage:


A person who comes to do a well qualified Job from another nation is called an expat.


Immigrant is used when usually a person/family just moves to another country to start a new life all together due to better economic or social conditions. natuarally doing small jobs to start with.


 


 


 

The text you are quoting:

Agree to you Nir. In normal english usage:


A person who comes to do a well qualified Job from another nation is called an expat.


Immigrant is used when usually a person/family just moves to another country to start a new life all together due to better economic or social conditions. natuarally doing small jobs to start with.


 


 


 


Sumit Thapliyal, Mar 14, 2015 @ 19:46
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Expat or Immigrant Worker?
Post 2

good topic. i also use expat to describe those with good office jobs, while using expat to describe a guy with a hard manual job of laying bricks or washing dishes feels bizzare.


i'm sure there's something not politically correct here however...Foot in Mouth

The text you are quoting:

good topic. i also use expat to describe those with good office jobs, while using expat to describe a guy with a hard manual job of laying bricks or washing dishes feels bizzare.


i'm sure there's something not politically correct here however...Foot in Mouth


Mark Spencer, Mar 14, 2015 @ 23:32
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Expat or Immigrant Worker?
Post 3

Is it possible that the reason "immigrant worker" feels wrong when applied to, for example, people from other countries working in Geneva, is that it's difficult to imagine most of them actually doing any work?

The text you are quoting:

Is it possible that the reason "immigrant worker" feels wrong when applied to, for example, people from other countries working in Geneva, is that it's difficult to imagine most of them actually doing any work?


Andy C, Mar 14, 2015 @ 23:58
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Expat or Immigrant Worker?
Post 4

Seriously, though: I find both terms to be despicable and outdated.


"Expat" has connotations of imperious priviledge; of self-entitled wankers drinking in colonial bars that the locals are only allowed into to sweep the floor.  In most countries that I've stayed in, I avoid anything described as "a popular expat hang-out" like I would avoid a rabid dog, because they are normally full of people who don't like where they're from, don't like where they are now, and are more than happy to tell you all about it.


Meanwhile, "immigrant worker" feels like a trite, dehumanisation of the wide variety of people who make the effort and sacrifices necessary to move to another country to earn a living.

The text you are quoting:

Seriously, though: I find both terms to be despicable and outdated.


"Expat" has connotations of imperious priviledge; of self-entitled wankers drinking in colonial bars that the locals are only allowed into to sweep the floor.  In most countries that I've stayed in, I avoid anything described as "a popular expat hang-out" like I would avoid a rabid dog, because they are normally full of people who don't like where they're from, don't like where they are now, and are more than happy to tell you all about it.


Meanwhile, "immigrant worker" feels like a trite, dehumanisation of the wide variety of people who make the effort and sacrifices necessary to move to another country to earn a living.


Andy C, Mar 15, 2015 @ 00:11
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Expat or Immigrant Worker?
Post 5

Seriously, though: I find both terms to be despicable and outdated.

"Expat" has connotations of imperious priviledge; of self-entitled wankers drinking in colonial bars that the locals are only allowed into to sweep the floor.  In most countries that I've stayed in, I avoid anything described as "a popular expat hang-out" like I would avoid a rabid dog, because they are normally full of people who don't like where they're from, don't like where they are now, and are more than happy to tell you all about it.

Meanwhile, "immigrant worker" feels like a trite, dehumanisation of the wide variety of people who make the effort and sacrifices necessary to move to another country to earn a living.


Mar 15, 15 00:11

I understand your point, Andy. Personally tho I don't have the same negative feelings about the word "expat", but I guess it depends on subjective personal experiences. Most foreginers I meet in Geneva call themselves "expats", but almost none of them fit the bad connotation of that word. 


Separately, I noticed the official communications of the City of Geneva don't talk about expats or migrante workers, but of the "International Community". What y'all think of that term?


 

The text you are quoting:

I understand your point, Andy. Personally tho I don't have the same negative feelings about the word "expat", but I guess it depends on subjective personal experiences. Most foreginers I meet in Geneva call themselves "expats", but almost none of them fit the bad connotation of that word. 


Separately, I noticed the official communications of the City of Geneva don't talk about expats or migrante workers, but of the "International Community". What y'all think of that term?


 


Nir Ofek, Mar 15, 2015 @ 11:56
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Expat or Immigrant Worker?
Post 6

I like better international community... 


 


 

The text you are quoting:

I like better international community... 


 


 


fatiha t, Mar 15, 2015 @ 14:22
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Expat or Immigrant Worker?
Post 7

But you can’t use “international community” to describe an individual, he/she is a member of, belongs to, or is part of, the international community.


I really don’t have any trouble with the word “expat”. I’m not ashamed of my origins nor do I have any compunction about frequenting -- admittedly, not every day -- an expat watering-hole, society, event, etc. They’re not necessarily exclusive opportunities to deride the local scene and its “natives”.


 


And just for the record, if anyone believes that the Swiss outside of CH aren’t expats, don’t have their  many societies – Gernan-, French-, Italian-speaking, yodelers, jass, etc., .  -- well, they have another think coming.


R.

The text you are quoting:

But you can’t use “international community” to describe an individual, he/she is a member of, belongs to, or is part of, the international community.


I really don’t have any trouble with the word “expat”. I’m not ashamed of my origins nor do I have any compunction about frequenting -- admittedly, not every day -- an expat watering-hole, society, event, etc. They’re not necessarily exclusive opportunities to deride the local scene and its “natives”.


 


And just for the record, if anyone believes that the Swiss outside of CH aren’t expats, don’t have their  many societies – Gernan-, French-, Italian-speaking, yodelers, jass, etc., .  -- well, they have another think coming.


R.


Ritchie, Mar 15, 2015 @ 17:01
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Expat or Immigrant Worker?
Post 8

I've always thought that the difference between the two terms depends on the perceived length of residence. 


The term "immigrant", to me, implies a long term possibly permanent relocation. If you get citizenship of the new country then you are definitely an immigrant. I described myself as an immigrant when I relocated to Australia from the UK for 20 years.


To me, "Expat" implies a temporary arrangement - the person has relocated for a while, There is probably no intention to remain in the new country permanently. I would think that describes a lot of the international community in Switzerland. I'd describe myself as an expat here.


I don't think this is related to skin colour, though possibly to socio-economic status.


Just my 2c!

The text you are quoting:

I've always thought that the difference between the two terms depends on the perceived length of residence. 


The term "immigrant", to me, implies a long term possibly permanent relocation. If you get citizenship of the new country then you are definitely an immigrant. I described myself as an immigrant when I relocated to Australia from the UK for 20 years.


To me, "Expat" implies a temporary arrangement - the person has relocated for a while, There is probably no intention to remain in the new country permanently. I would think that describes a lot of the international community in Switzerland. I'd describe myself as an expat here.


I don't think this is related to skin colour, though possibly to socio-economic status.


Just my 2c!


kathyl, Mar 15, 2015 @ 17:42
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Expat or Immigrant Worker?
Post 9

I've always thought that the difference between the two terms depends on the perceived length of residence. 

The term "immigrant", to me, implies a long term possibly permanent relocation. If you get citizenship of the new country then you are definitely an immigrant. I described myself as an immigrant when I relocated to Australia from the UK for 20 years.

To me, "Expat" implies a temporary arrangement - the person has relocated for a while, There is probably no intention to remain in the new country permanently. I would think that describes a lot of the international community in Switzerland. I'd describe myself as an expat here.

I don't think this is related to skin colour, though possibly to socio-economic status.

Just my 2c!


Mar 15, 15 17:42

i dont think its related to to the length of residence. i know people who are in geneva 20 years working for p&g, and they refer themselves as expats. take a vp at p&g who has been here for 20 year and put the label immigrant worker on her...doesn't feel right, does it?


 

The text you are quoting:

i dont think its related to to the length of residence. i know people who are in geneva 20 years working for p&g, and they refer themselves as expats. take a vp at p&g who has been here for 20 year and put the label immigrant worker on her...doesn't feel right, does it?


 


Mark Spencer, Mar 15, 2015 @ 19:01
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Expat or Immigrant Worker?
Post 10

Didn't you read the papers? A white US expat , Brady Dougan is stepping down as CEO of Credit Suisse ("The Local" and other papers) and is being replaced, in the words of the Swiss paper "La Croix":  by "a noir", Tidjane Thiam, in "a country like ours, where immigrants find it hard to climb to positions of high responsiblity".


Now read that last sentence again carefully.


Here are some links:


The Local


http://www.thelocal.ch/20150310/us-expat-stepping-down-as-credit-suisse-ceo


Le Temps


http://www.letemps.ch/Page/Uuid/eef6c0ce-c804-11e4-959d-74804f4bcbe7/Comment_dire_un_Noir_%C3%A0_la_t%C3%AAte_de_Credit_Suisse_En_le_disant


Lx croix


http://www.la-croix.com/Actualite/Monde/Afrique/Un-franco-ivoirien-prend-la-tete-de-Credit-Suisse-2015-03-10-1289618


«Un Noir à la tête d’une grande banque: dans un pays comme le nôtre, où les personnes issues de l’immigration rencontrent bien des difficultés à accéder aux plus hautes responsabilités, le symbole serait frappant. Las, cette nomination n’a pas eu lieu dans un établissement financier hexagonal, mais dans une banque helvétique.»


Editorial by "Le Temps" on the hiring of Tidjane Thiam


This is undoubtedly the best response the business world could give to the February 9 initiative [to curb immigration, rejected by French-speaking cantons but approved by the German-speaking majority]. In order to prosper, Switzerland needs bright workers for whom recruiters also need to look abroad.”


So, why wasn't the hiring of Brady Dougan, dubbed an American expat considered a statement on immigration? And why is highly educated, Thiam, with a stellar record as high government official and Business executive an immigrant.


The comment in "The Guardian" was not on how you use the terms, Nir, but on how they are used by many mainstream outlets.


 



The text you are quoting:

Didn't you read the papers? A white US expat , Brady Dougan is stepping down as CEO of Credit Suisse ("The Local" and other papers) and is being replaced, in the words of the Swiss paper "La Croix":  by "a noir", Tidjane Thiam, in "a country like ours, where immigrants find it hard to climb to positions of high responsiblity".


Now read that last sentence again carefully.


Here are some links:


The Local


http://www.thelocal.ch/20150310/us-expat-stepping-down-as-credit-suisse-ceo


Le Temps


http://www.letemps.ch/Page/Uuid/eef6c0ce-c804-11e4-959d-74804f4bcbe7/Comment_dire_un_Noir_%C3%A0_la_t%C3%AAte_de_Credit_Suisse_En_le_disant


Lx croix


http://www.la-croix.com/Actualite/Monde/Afrique/Un-franco-ivoirien-prend-la-tete-de-Credit-Suisse-2015-03-10-1289618


«Un Noir à la tête d’une grande banque: dans un pays comme le nôtre, où les personnes issues de l’immigration rencontrent bien des difficultés à accéder aux plus hautes responsabilités, le symbole serait frappant. Las, cette nomination n’a pas eu lieu dans un établissement financier hexagonal, mais dans une banque helvétique.»


Editorial by "Le Temps" on the hiring of Tidjane Thiam


This is undoubtedly the best response the business world could give to the February 9 initiative [to curb immigration, rejected by French-speaking cantons but approved by the German-speaking majority]. In order to prosper, Switzerland needs bright workers for whom recruiters also need to look abroad.”


So, why wasn't the hiring of Brady Dougan, dubbed an American expat considered a statement on immigration? And why is highly educated, Thiam, with a stellar record as high government official and Business executive an immigrant.


The comment in "The Guardian" was not on how you use the terms, Nir, but on how they are used by many mainstream outlets.


 


JR M, Mar 15, 2015 @ 21:53
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Expat or Immigrant Worker?
Post 11

http://www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals-network/2015/mar/13/white-people-expats-immigrants-migration

The text you are quoting:

http://www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals-network/2015/mar/13/white-people-expats-immigrants-migration


V N, Mar 16, 2015 @ 11:13
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Expat or Immigrant Worker?
Post 12

Ok thats what started the whole thread!!!!Sealed

The text you are quoting:

Ok thats what started the whole thread!!!!Sealed


V N, Mar 16, 2015 @ 11:14
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
12 Replies | 1910 Views      |  Send to friend
 
 
 
Feedback Form