Login or Sign Up
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Global Forums > General > Is this racist?
 
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Is this racist?

Personally, I think it's hilarious...


 


First Nations trio A Tribe Called Red is in the hot seat after one of its members wore a t-shirt modeled after the Cleveland MLB baseball team with the word “Caucasians” written across the front. Travis Lupick over at The Straight has more:



Promotional photographs show Ian Campeau (aka DJ NDN) sporting an ironic version of the Cleveland jersey that’s been altered to read “Caucasians” instead of “Indians.” It also includes a white head with a dollar sign above it instead of the baseball team logo’s Indian face and feather.
According to a message Campeau posted on Instagram, at least one concert promoter has received emails calling for the cancellation of a show scheduled for June 13 to 15.
“So we’re suppose to play Westfest next Sunday,” Campeau wrote. “The organizers have been receiving thinly veiled threatening e-mails in protest to me performing. Here’s one of them. This is my hometown. So disappointing.”


Campeau also posted screenshots of e-mails sent to local promoters, one of which read, in part: “I must take issue with you booking a racist, hypocritical band, A Tribe Called Red. If any non-Native band featured some of the song they do like Indian Girl, no doubt TRC member, Ian Campeau, who has been showing wearing a racist T-shirt, would be making a complaint to the human rights commission.”
We hear the term “reverse racism” all the time, and researchers have found that whites think it’s on the rise. The problem is that arguments ignore the systemic racism that exists and give people actual cultural, political and financial power in society. It’s why the Washington DC NFL football team and Cleveland’s MLB baseball team is allowed to keep their racist names and make millions of dollars off of racist iconography, and there actually has to be a debate about why that’s unacceptable. Campeau’s T-shirt is a snarky retort to way that Native imagery is used — constantly — in our culture.





The text you are quoting:

Personally, I think it's hilarious...


 


First Nations trio A Tribe Called Red is in the hot seat after one of its members wore a t-shirt modeled after the Cleveland MLB baseball team with the word “Caucasians” written across the front. Travis Lupick over at The Straight has more:



Promotional photographs show Ian Campeau (aka DJ NDN) sporting an ironic version of the Cleveland jersey that’s been altered to read “Caucasians” instead of “Indians.” It also includes a white head with a dollar sign above it instead of the baseball team logo’s Indian face and feather.
According to a message Campeau posted on Instagram, at least one concert promoter has received emails calling for the cancellation of a show scheduled for June 13 to 15.
“So we’re suppose to play Westfest next Sunday,” Campeau wrote. “The organizers have been receiving thinly veiled threatening e-mails in protest to me performing. Here’s one of them. This is my hometown. So disappointing.”


Campeau also posted screenshots of e-mails sent to local promoters, one of which read, in part: “I must take issue with you booking a racist, hypocritical band, A Tribe Called Red. If any non-Native band featured some of the song they do like Indian Girl, no doubt TRC member, Ian Campeau, who has been showing wearing a racist T-shirt, would be making a complaint to the human rights commission.”
We hear the term “reverse racism” all the time, and researchers have found that whites think it’s on the rise. The problem is that arguments ignore the systemic racism that exists and give people actual cultural, political and financial power in society. It’s why the Washington DC NFL football team and Cleveland’s MLB baseball team is allowed to keep their racist names and make millions of dollars off of racist iconography, and there actually has to be a debate about why that’s unacceptable. Campeau’s T-shirt is a snarky retort to way that Native imagery is used — constantly — in our culture.


CasuistikJun 20, 2014 @ 07:49
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
 
8 Replies | 1343 Views      |  Send to friend
 
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Is this racist?
Post 1

Bloody PC world gone mad...next in line will be the All Blacks !!

The text you are quoting:

Bloody PC world gone mad...next in line will be the All Blacks !!


Jeffery S, Jun 20, 2014 @ 07:56
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Is this racist?
Post 2

Tired of this kinda BS, you can`t do or say shit anymore or some a*hole somewhere will "feel insulted".

The text you are quoting:

Tired of this kinda BS, you can`t do or say shit anymore or some a*hole somewhere will "feel insulted".


ThomasNL, Jun 20, 2014 @ 10:27
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Is this racist?
Post 3

Personally, I think it's hilarious...

 

First Nations trio A Tribe Called Red is in the hot seat after one of its members wore a t-shirt modeled after the Cleveland MLB baseball team with the word “Caucasians” written across the front. Travis Lupick over at The Straight has more:


Promotional photographs show Ian Campeau (aka DJ NDN) sporting an ironic version of the Cleveland jersey that’s been altered to read “Caucasians” instead of “Indians.” It also includes a white head with a dollar sign above it instead of the baseball team logo’s Indian face and feather.
According to a message Campeau posted on Instagram, at least one concert promoter has received emails calling for the cancellation of a show scheduled for June 13 to 15.
“So we’re suppose to play Westfest next Sunday,” Campeau wrote. “The organizers have been receiving thinly veiled threatening e-mails in protest to me performing. Here’s one of them. This is my hometown. So disappointing.”

Campeau also posted screenshots of e-mails sent to local promoters, one of which read, in part: “I must take issue with you booking a racist, hypocritical band, A Tribe Called Red. If any non-Native band featured some of the song they do like Indian Girl, no doubt TRC member, Ian Campeau, who has been showing wearing a racist T-shirt, would be making a complaint to the human rights commission.”
We hear the term “reverse racism” all the time, and researchers have found that whites think it’s on the rise. The problem is that arguments ignore the systemic racism that exists and give people actual cultural, political and financial power in society. It’s why the Washington DC NFL football team and Cleveland’s MLB baseball team is allowed to keep their racist names and make millions of dollars off of racist iconography, and there actually has to be a debate about why that’s unacceptable. Campeau’s T-shirt is a snarky retort to way that Native imagery is used — constantly — in our culture.


Jun 20, 14 07:49

Caucasian?! You can't use that word! That's OUR word! Only we can use that word! etc, etc. Laughing

The text you are quoting:

Caucasian?! You can't use that word! That's OUR word! Only we can use that word! etc, etc. Laughing


Rich, Jun 20, 2014 @ 10:59
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Is this racist?
Post 4

It's been suggested that redskin is a term used to describe the bloodied scalp of a butchered Native American. Whether or not that's true, these people suffered a lot. There's no harm in being sensitive to their feelings. I'm quite happy that I hear the words nigger and paki a lot less than I used to.

The text you are quoting:

It's been suggested that redskin is a term used to describe the bloodied scalp of a butchered Native American. Whether or not that's true, these people suffered a lot. There's no harm in being sensitive to their feelings. I'm quite happy that I hear the words nigger and paki a lot less than I used to.


Amy Soska, Jun 20, 2014 @ 11:11
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Is this racist?
Post 5

Interesting post.


However, I see it as a case, as is so often, of “wanting to have your cake and eat it” or wanting to have the best of both worlds.


If the band didn’t take themselves so seriously, then it would be an amusing little poke at dollar-loving Caucasians (as the logo implies) and it would be seen as nothing more than a joke, not racist nor reverse racist.


However this is an individual (group of individuals) who DO take themselves very seriously indeed to the extent that they forbid non-indigenous people (using the term “Aboriginals” slightly out of context) from wearing any type of Native Indian headresses or “war paint” to their gigs – an entitlement awarded only to their Native Indian fans.


In addition, their spokesman, Campeau filed a human rights complaint himself, against an amateur football club for using the name “Redskins”.


So if you’re going to be so sensitive and serious about your own ancestry, then perhaps a little mutual respect for other’s ancestries would not go amiss.


IMHO it’s neither racist nor reverse racist, but it’s also “not big, not clever and not very funny”.

The text you are quoting:

Interesting post.


However, I see it as a case, as is so often, of “wanting to have your cake and eat it” or wanting to have the best of both worlds.


If the band didn’t take themselves so seriously, then it would be an amusing little poke at dollar-loving Caucasians (as the logo implies) and it would be seen as nothing more than a joke, not racist nor reverse racist.


However this is an individual (group of individuals) who DO take themselves very seriously indeed to the extent that they forbid non-indigenous people (using the term “Aboriginals” slightly out of context) from wearing any type of Native Indian headresses or “war paint” to their gigs – an entitlement awarded only to their Native Indian fans.


In addition, their spokesman, Campeau filed a human rights complaint himself, against an amateur football club for using the name “Redskins”.


So if you’re going to be so sensitive and serious about your own ancestry, then perhaps a little mutual respect for other’s ancestries would not go amiss.


IMHO it’s neither racist nor reverse racist, but it’s also “not big, not clever and not very funny”.


Carolyn C, Jun 20, 2014 @ 10:13
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Is this racist?
Post 6

"Reverse racism" is a nonsense to me,it seems,since racism is about power relationships and not just race.


i think the T shirt is a very clever idea and makes a point that could get people thinking about a lot of the casual racism that we all take for granted.


and there's nothing wrong with making people stop and think....

The text you are quoting:

"Reverse racism" is a nonsense to me,it seems,since racism is about power relationships and not just race.


i think the T shirt is a very clever idea and makes a point that could get people thinking about a lot of the casual racism that we all take for granted.


and there's nothing wrong with making people stop and think....


buzzcocks, Jun 20, 2014 @ 14:54
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Is this racist?
Post 7

can't find a shortened clip of this, but the part relevant to this thread starts at 3:25  

The text you are quoting:

can't find a shortened clip of this, but the part relevant to this thread starts at 3:25  


G___, Jun 20, 2014 @ 15:44
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
Only members can see photos
Only members can see names and photos
Re: Is this racist?
Post 8

Quite funny but...a bit simplistic in argument.Racism isn't just about words,the acceptance of the language leads to acceptance of the attitudes and then what follows.


Easy for a member of  a priveliged group( white,male,professional) to laugh off the effects of what is " offensive",especially when,as I said above,words are the tip of the iceberg.


 


 

The text you are quoting:

Quite funny but...a bit simplistic in argument.Racism isn't just about words,the acceptance of the language leads to acceptance of the attitudes and then what follows.


Easy for a member of  a priveliged group( white,male,professional) to laugh off the effects of what is " offensive",especially when,as I said above,words are the tip of the iceberg.


 


 


buzzcocks, Jun 20, 2014 @ 16:06
Your Reply:
Reply  Reply With Quote  Thank Poster
! Report to Admin
8 Replies | 1343 Views      |  Send to friend
 
 
 
Feedback Form